Stop Comparing Your Players to Each Other
Hyvia Team

Walk into any boot room on a Friday afternoon and you'll find the kit man laying out tomorrow's footwear. Thirty pairs, give or take. A 42 here, a 45 there, and one centre-back who needs a 47 and has never once been able to borrow a spare.
Now imagine he worked out the squad's average size, rounded it to 44, and handed everyone the same pair.
Nobody would ever do that. It's absurd. And yet, in performance departments all over the world, we do something very close to it every morning, with numbers that matter far more than boots.
The traffic lights on the wall
You've probably seen the chart. Sometimes it's on a screen in the performance office, sometimes it's printed and taped to the wall. Every player in a row, a column of numbers next to each name, and a splash of colour: green, amber, red.
The cut-offs behind those colours are usually set across the whole squad. Below a certain HRV, you're amber. Above a certain resting heart rate, you're red. It looks objective. It feels scientific. And for a surprising number of players, it's quietly telling the staff the wrong story.
Here's the first problem. Some players are simply built differently. A player whose heart rate variability naturally sits low will show up amber or red day after day, however fresh he feels. After a few weeks, everyone learns to ignore his row. Which means that on the day his numbers genuinely drop, nobody notices.
The second problem is the mirror image, and it's worse. A player with naturally high numbers can slide a long way down from his own normal and still sit comfortably in the green. On the chart he looks like the fittest man in the building. In reality he might be having his toughest week of the season.
The chart isn't lying, exactly. It's answering a question nobody needed answered: how does this player compare to his teammates? What the staff actually need to know is something else entirely. How does this player compare to himself?
Normal is a person, not a number
If you want to see how wide "normal" really is, there's a lovely piece of research from the Scripps Research Translational Institute. In 2020, a team led by Giorgio Quer published an analysis in PLOS ONE of resting heart rate data from 92,457 adults who wore wrist trackers for up to two years. That's nearly 33 million days of readings.
The headline finding: one person's normal resting heart rate could differ from another's by as much as 70 beats per minute. Age, sex, body mass and sleep together explained less than 10% of that spread. Yet each person's own resting heart rate stayed remarkably steady over time, with only occasional episodes outside their usual range.
"It was surprising to see how vastly different 'normal' looked for different people," Quer said when the study came out.
That study wasn't about footballers, and a professional squad is a far more uniform group than the general public. But the principle carries straight onto the training ground. Every player arrives with his own normal, shaped by genetics, training history, age and a dozen things nobody will ever measure. Two equally fit, equally healthy midfielders can produce readings that look worlds apart. Neither of them is wrong.
Every body wobbles
There's a second reason a single number on a single morning can mislead you: bodies are noisy.
Heart rate variability in particular moves around a lot from one day to the next, even when nothing meaningful has changed. In a widely cited 2014 review in Frontiers in Physiology, the sports scientist Martin Buchheit put the natural day-to-day variation of a common HRV measure at roughly 10 to 20%. A bad night, a heavy dinner, a stressful drive in, and the number shifts.
So the useful question isn't "did it go down?" It's "did it go down by more than it normally wobbles?" Buchheit's advice is to judge every change against two things at once: how much that measure naturally bounces around, and the smallest change that actually matters in practice. A drop smaller than the usual wobble is just noise. A drop bigger than both is worth a conversation.
He makes another point every performance coach could pin above their desk. In the work he reviewed, links between heart rate measures and running performance only showed up when readings were averaged over at least three or four days. Single-day readings didn't cut it.
The same idea runs through Daniel Plews' doctoral research at Auckland University of Technology, working with world-class endurance athletes. Weekly HRV averages tracked changes in running performance far better than single-day values. And in a case study of two triathletes, the one who slid into non-functional overreaching showed a steady decline in their weekly HRV average, measured against their own threshold for a meaningful change. The other athlete's line held steady.
Notice what all of this has in common. None of it compares athletes with each other. It compares each athlete with their own history, over enough days to see past the noise.
What a baseline actually is
"Baseline" gets used a lot, so it's worth being precise about what we mean.
A baseline isn't one magic number. It's a player's normal range: where his readings usually sit, and how much they usually move. It takes time to build, because you need enough days to see both the level and the wobble. And it isn't fixed. A player's normal in the second week of pre-season won't be his normal in March, and it shouldn't be.
That has a few practical consequences that are easy to forget:
- New signings need patience. In their first weeks, you don't yet know what normal looks like for them, so treat early readings as information you're gathering, not verdicts.
- Breaks reset things. After a winter break or a long spell away from the club, give the baseline a little time to settle again.
- Trends beat days. One low morning is a footnote. Several mornings drifting the same way is a story.
What this looks like at HYVIA
This is the thinking behind everything on the HYVIA Coach Dashboard. All six outputs (Readiness, Stress, Fatigue, Performance Score, Overload and Sleep) are benchmarked against each player's own historical baseline, never against a squad average or a population chart. The Band's heart rate, HRV and sleep data and the Patch's sweat chemistry all feed into that same picture.
So when a player's Readiness dips, it means he's lower than he usually is, not lower than the left-back. The striker whose numbers always look modest isn't permanently flagged. The winger whose numbers always look brilliant can't hide a slide behind them.
It also changes how staff can talk to players. "Your numbers are worse than his" is a comparison nobody wants to hear, and it invites an argument. "You're a bit below your own normal this week" is about him and only him. That's a much easier conversation to have honestly.
A few habits worth starting tomorrow
You don't need any particular technology to start thinking this way. A few small shifts make a real difference:
- Take the leaderboard off the wall. Ranking players against each other on physiological data rewards genetics, not readiness. If you want a chart, show each player against his own last few weeks.
- Ask "compared to what?" Whenever a number looks alarming, check what that player's normal is before deciding whether it's alarming at all.
- Look at the week, not the morning. Averages over several days are kinder to the noise and closer to the truth.
- Let players know their own normal. When a player knows where he usually sits, a dip makes sense to him too, and he's far more likely to tell you why.
Back to the boot room
Nobody would hand a whole squad size-44 boots. Everyone in football understands, without being told, that feet come in different sizes and the kit has to fit the player.
Physiology is no different. It's just harder to see. Each player arrives with his own normal, and the most useful number in the building is rarely how he compares to his teammates. It's how today compares to the rest of his season.
Stop comparing your players to each other. Compare each of them to himself.
If you'd like to see how HYVIA tracks every player against his own baseline, book a demo with our team. We'd love to show you.
Sources
- Inter- and intraindividual variability in daily resting heart rate and its associations with age, sex, sleep, BMI, and time of year: Retrospective, longitudinal cohort study of 92,457 adults - PLOS ONE, 2020
- As fitness wearables near ubiquity, resting heart rate poised to become 'vital sign of the digital age' - Scripps Research, 2020
- Monitoring training status with HR measures: do all roads lead to Rome? - Frontiers in Physiology, 2014
- The practical application of heart rate variability: monitoring training adaptation in world class athletes - Doctoral thesis, Auckland University of Technology, 2014